A couple of months ago, when things were really going wrong for Ryan Garko, I started wondering, “Is this guy the next Brian Daubach?”
August 18th, 2008 | Josh Fagan | 0 comments | ContinuedArchive for Josh Fagan
Duchscherer Comes Through: Justin Duchscherer Scouting Report
Last night Justin Duchscherer won his tenth game of the season. He’s 10-2 with a 1.78 ERA and a 0.88 WHIP. It won’t last; don’t think that it’ll last. But it’s interesting to analyze the guy who’s suddenly the best pitcher in baseball.
July 9th, 2008 | Josh Fagan | 0 comments | Continued
Stop Signing Jeff Weaver
In 2007 Weaver proved that he could not pitch in the American League. His 6.20/1.53/.315 OBA line was the equivalent of a 15-second 100 metre dash. He wasn’t as bad as some guy behind you at Baskin Robbins, but he wasn’t as good as the mediocre standard of the fifth starter.
July 7th, 2008 | Josh Fagan | 0 comments | Continued
Manny Being Manny; And The Young, Functionally Disabled Boy Who Coined That Phrase
As a way of explaining behaviour, Manny being Manny is right up there with the cornmeal theory of infectious disease. It’s the perfect shield for sports announcers who might otherwise be forced to give some kind of personal insight, some kind of tendentious offering, some kind of…you know…opinion.
July 2nd, 2008 | Josh Fagan | 0 comments | Continued
Gabriel Morency’s Hat
A couple years ago Gabriel Morency was talking about the Dallas Cowboys. “I take my hat off to Tony Romo,” Morency said. Then he continued, saying something about the Patriots and the Chargers, but the “hat” line was what intrigued me.
June 24th, 2008 | Josh Fagan | 1 comment | Continued
Adam Dunn Rips Toronto? Slams Canadian Currency?
This morning a friend emailed me a link to a Kevin Kaduk blog post presenting (rather than dissecting) the “feud” between Jays’s GM J.P. Ricciardi and Reds’s man-mountain Adam Dunn. I hesitate to call it a feud, because, really, it has all the electricity and potential for violence of a Chad Michael Murray haircut.
June 20th, 2008 | Josh Fagan | 0 comments | Continued
Santiago Casilla Scouting Report: Close to Closing
The first time that I saw Santiago Casilla pitch, I rushed to one of my fantasy mags. I wanted to know what people were writing about a youngish eighth-inning guy with a mid-90s moving fastball and an unhittable power slider. “Dollar pick,” the magazine said. “Not worth more than late-round, reserve look.” Wrong.
June 20th, 2008 | Josh Fagan | 0 comments | Continued
Greg Smith Scouting Report: Old Glavine
Greg Smith’s cooled down a little after a hot start, but he’s still someone to look at as a source of long-term value. As a lefty pitching in Oakland’s massive meadow, he’s got the benefit of history on his side. Mark Mulder, Barry Zito, and Dana Eveland: all lefties with cutters who’ve made their bones in Oakland.
June 20th, 2008 | Josh Fagan | 0 comments | Continued
Major League Baseball’s Worst (Ever?) Player: Tony Pena Jr.
We all know the power of nepotism. It’s why so many celebrities have children with gold and platinum records. It’s why Mordecai Richler’s family could build a cabin out of books they’ve published. It’s why Harvard’s endowment could build and launch into orbit a second, cheese-filled moon. But a baseball player getting a shot in the majors?
June 18th, 2008 | Josh Fagan | 0 comments | Continued
Justin Masterson Scouting Report
As a Clay Buchholz owner I’ve kind of been a little impatient with the Sox’s strategy of calling up every AAA pitcher who can’t be moulded, fired, glazed, fired, and glazed again. Other than reading a quick paragraph in one of my fantasy magazines, I had no idea who or what Justin Masterson was. And now I understand why he was ranked as the third-best prospect going into 2009: This guy is good.
June 18th, 2008 | Josh Fagan | 0 comments | ContinuedThe Myth of the Good At-Bat
I’ve always hated “good at-bats.” If we’re talking about a hitter who gets himself into a good count, then goes the other way for a hit, the expression works. But if the hitter’s just not very good, and all he can is try to work a walk, then, no, that’s not a good at-bat.
June 15th, 2008 | Josh Fagan | 2 comments | Continued
Tony Pena Scouting Report: See Ya Next Year
With Pena’s ERA down to 2.84, I thought I’d show him a little respect and take a quick look at this guy’s situation. Pena, 26, is pitching the eighth for Arizona. He’s blocked by Brandon Lyon, who, at 28, is getting both drumsticks and the end-piece of the meatloaf.
June 14th, 2008 | Josh Fagan | 0 comments | Continued
Will Matt Cain Ever Be Worth Owning?
I can’t help but wonder whether Matt Cain’s destined to be the next Jeremy Bonderman: a guy with great potential who’s always a start away from being a $20 pitcher; but a guy who, until he’s that $20 pitcher, will always be overhyped and overpriced.
June 7th, 2008 | Josh Fagan | 0 comments | Continued
Alex “GIDP” Rios
With 105 games left in the baseball season, Rios has grounded into ten double plays. That doesn’t seem like a lot, but consider this: In 711 ‘07 plate appearances, Rios grounded into nine twin killings; in 498 ‘06 at bats, six.
Why Not Josh Fields? Josh Fields Scouting Report
On May 8 Josh Fields was sent to the DL with tendinitis in his right knee. For fifteen days, that’s all we knew. He had tendinitis in his knee. He wasn’t playing. He’d be back…eventually. Well, now he is back–kind of.
May 30th, 2008 | Josh Fagan | 0 comments | Continued
Is Eric Wedge Baseball’s Worst Manager
The last couple days the big story’s been Willie Randolph’s spot on the firing line. The Mets aren’t sharp, and it’s Willie’s turn to answer for their sub-.500 record. But at 24-26, it’s hardly a crisis. I can’t say the same about the Indians.
May 28th, 2008 | Josh Fagan | 0 comments | Continued
Jose Arredondo Scouting Report: 1A
Arredondo is Francisco Rodriguez. He looks like Rodriguez, he has the same arm action as Rodriguez, and he lands exactly the same as Rodriguez. He’s the same height as Rodriguez, and he weighs the same as Rodriguez.
Athletes Just Don’t Die
I’m busy dodging the treacly stories on Jon Lester’s triumphant return to health/MLB/no-hit status. Not because I’m a bitter cynic (which I am) but because this story’s Hollywood ending was never in doubt…
May 21st, 2008 | Josh Fagan | 2 comments | Continued
Clint Barmes Rides Again; or Venison Steaks For All
It’s happened. Call it inevitable; say what you want. The alternative was just too absurd. A Rockies batter who hits .220! Impossible. Can’t happen; can’t be true. This rondure turns, and we’re back to reality.
May 20th, 2008 | Josh Fagan | 0 comments | ContinuedRichard Griffin Is An Idiot
Griffin’s quiver has one arrow: J.P. Ricciardi is an idiot. He doesn’t say it in those words, but the thrust is clear. Ricciardi’s in his seventh year as the G.M. of the Toronto Blue Jays, and the club still hasn’t won a pennant.
May 20th, 2008 | Josh Fagan | 0 comments | Continued
Hoffman’s Done; No Bell Pun
You’ve got Hoffman closing games, you’ve got Heath Bell setting up, and you’ve got the Padres a dime under .500. That’d be fine if it were 1996, but with Hoffman toeing the horizon, something’s going to change.
May 17th, 2008 | Josh Fagan | 1 comment | Continued


